Italy Same-Sex Adoption Rulings: A Legal Victory, a Painful Exclusion and a Country Still Divided on Family Equality

Italy’s Constitutional Court has opened joint adult adoption to civil partners but left international adoption reform to Parliament. Two rulings, one persistent contradiction, and a difficult reminder of how far LGBTQ+ family equality still has to go.

Italy’s Same-Sex Adoption Debate Exposes a Deep Legal Contradiction

Italy has delivered two important Constitutional Court decisions on adoption, and together they reveal just how complicated the country’s approach to LGBTQ+ family equality remains.

On 12 November 2026, the Italian Constitutional Court published rulings 194/2026 and 195/2026, both concerning adoption and civil partnerships. One removes a discriminatory restriction affecting the adoption of adults. The other leaves the existing framework for international adoption of minors unchanged, with responsibility for any wider reform resting with Parliament.

For a country that places such extraordinary emphasis on the importance of family, the contrast is difficult to ignore.

The judgments are legally distinct, and their different outcomes should not be confused. Nevertheless, they highlight the fragmented way in which Italy continues to recognise family relationships, particularly where same-sex couples are concerned.

What Did the Italian Constitutional Court Actually Decide?

The first ruling represents genuine progress.

In judgment 195/2026, the Court declared unconstitutional a provision that prevented two people in a civil partnership from jointly adopting the same adult.

The judges recognised that civil partnerships constitute a legally protected family relationship and that preventing an adult from being adopted by both partners could disproportionately interfere with established family bonds.

This matters because adult adoption is not simply a legal formality. It can recognise longstanding emotional relationships, family responsibilities and personal identity.

The second case concerned a different situation: whether civil partners should be permitted to apply jointly for international adoption of a child.

In judgment 194/2026, the Court declared the constitutional challenge inadmissible at this stage, reasoning that changing the relevant eligibility framework would require broader legislative choices involving the best interests of children and the structure of international adoption law.

Consequently, the existing restrictions remain in place.

This was not a ruling that same-sex couples are unsuitable parents. It was a decision about the constitutional limits of judicial intervention in an area the Court considered to require legislative assessment.

Why Can Single People Apply While Same-Sex Civil Partners Remain Excluded?

One of the most difficult aspects of the current legal framework becomes apparent when the two judgments are considered alongside earlier developments.

In 2025, the Constitutional Court removed the categorical exclusion preventing single people from applying for international adoption. That ruling recognised the importance of evaluating prospective adoptive parents rather than automatically excluding an entire category of applicants.

Yet the ordinary joint international adoption process remains unavailable to civil partners.

Under Italy’s existing legislation, eligibility for joint international adoption is linked to marriage. Same-sex couples cannot marry under Italian law, which instead provides for civil partnerships, introduced in 2016.

The result is a structural distinction between married couples and civil partners. It is not resolved simply because individual applicants have gained access through a separate legal route.

The Court’s latest judgment acknowledges that family law has evolved considerably since the existing international adoption framework was established.

It also recalls previous constitutional rulings recognising that sexual orientation does not, in itself, determine a person’s ability to assume parental responsibilities.

That makes the continuing legal distinction especially important to examine.

If suitability is assessed through an individual process, the rationale for excluding a legally recognised couple as a category deserves careful scrutiny.

A Couple Already Assessed as Suitable, but Still Facing a Legal Barrier

Protester from “Rainbow Families Italy” with a poster saying “We are Families, not crimes”.

There is an especially revealing detail in the case behind ruling 194/2026.

According to the judgment, the couple had already undergone preliminary checks as part of the proceedings. Police enquiries revealed no relevant criminal issues, and the competent social and health services expressed a favourable assessment of their suitability for international adoption.

Yet their application encountered the existing statutory restriction affecting civil partners.

That does not mean an international adoption would necessarily have been authorised if the restriction did not exist. International adoption requires further procedures, assessments and cooperation with the country of origin.

But it illustrates why categorical eligibility rules matter.

The couple’s situation was not merely hypothetical. It involved people whose circumstances had been examined, whose suitability had received a favourable preliminary assessment and whose legal status nevertheless remained an obstacle.

For those concerned about equal treatment, this is perhaps the most important element of the entire case.

The Decision Returns to Parliament, but Who Takes Responsibility?

The Constitutional Court has made clear that Parliament must consider whether and how international adoption legislation should evolve.

There are legitimate reasons for this division of responsibilities. Constitutional courts cannot simply replace legislatures, and international adoption involves complex questions concerning children’s welfare, safeguards, overseas authorities and different family structures.

But recognising those constitutional limits does not erase the consequences of leaving the present law unchanged.

For LGBTQ+ families, the problem is that legal recognition has frequently advanced through individual cases while comprehensive legislative reform has remained elusive.

One judgment recognises a family bond. Another identifies changes in the legal landscape but leaves broader reform to elected lawmakers. The people affected remain subject to the existing restrictions.

That is why the outcome can feel like an institutional game of passing responsibility, even where each institution has a legally defensible explanation for its role.

The question now is whether Parliament will revisit the law, and whether any reform will give serious consideration to the needs of children and the capacities of prospective parents without relying exclusively on traditional marital categories.

The Meloni Government and Italy’s Political Responsibility

Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni

The political context is an essential part of this discussion.

Italy’s current government is led by Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni and a coalition including Brothers of Italy, the League and Forza Italia. In the international adoption proceedings, the Presidency of the Council of Ministers, represented by the State Attorney’s Office, argued that the constitutional challenge should be declared inadmissible or unfounded.

That intervention is documented in the judgment itself.

The government’s legal position does not prove that it opposes every possible reform of international adoption. It does, however, show that the state defended the existing framework in these proceedings.

The historical background of Brothers of Italy is also relevant to understanding the country’s political debate. As Reuters has documented, the party traces part of its lineage to Italy’s post-war neo-fascist movement. Meloni has rejected fascism and condemned expressions of fascist nostalgia within her party, presenting Brothers of Italy as a mainstream conservative political force.

Those historical facts, public statements and present-day legal positions should be evaluated distinctly.

For critics of the government’s approach, the central concern is not simply the party’s history. It is whether contemporary family legislation gives same-sex couples a fair opportunity to be considered under the same standards applied to other prospective parents.

The latest judgments offer a concrete basis for that debate.

Why This Feels Personal for Italians Living Abroad

For those of us with Italian roots, there is something especially painful about watching these legal debates unfold from abroad.

Italy is a country I associate with extraordinary creativity, culture, warmth and a fiercely expressed devotion to family. Yet when I look at the legal recognition available to LGBTQ+ couples, I struggle to reconcile that image with the restrictions that remain.

Sometimes, the distance between Italy’s cultural sophistication and its family legislation feels almost centuries wide.

It is difficult not to feel disappointed when a country capable of so much progress continues to debate whether families that already exist should be afforded fuller legal recognition.

And perhaps the most frustrating aspect is not that Italy has made no progress. It clearly has.

Civil partnerships were introduced in 2016. Courts have recognised additional parental relationships and removed certain restrictions. The judgments published this month are further evidence that the legal framework continues to evolve.

But the resulting protections remain uneven.

From an international perspective, that fragmented progress creates uncomfortable comparisons with other European countries where same-sex marriage and joint adoption have been recognised through comprehensive legislation.

The Gayly Mirror has previously examined the difficulties faced by same-sex couples seeking to adopt in Hungary, another example of how family recognition can depend on complex interactions between politics, courts and administrative rules.

Italy’s circumstances are different, but the broader question is familiar: how long should couples wait for lawmakers to address legal distinctions affecting their family lives?

Children’s Interests Must Remain at the Centre

International adoption is not a right to obtain a child. It is a carefully regulated process intended to protect children who need families.

Any reform must therefore maintain rigorous safeguards, comprehensive assessments, international cooperation and proper attention to the child’s best interests.

Opening eligibility to additional categories of prospective adoptive parents would not guarantee approval in individual cases, nor would it compel another country to permit a particular adoption.

However, the child’s interests must also be considered when assessing whether excluding categories of prospective parents is justified.

The Constitutional Court itself noted that an excessively restrictive framework can affect the possibility of finding stable and supportive families for children.

It also acknowledged the significance of earlier rulings concerning parental suitability and the absence of evidence that a same-sex family necessarily produces negative developmental outcomes for children.

Those observations do not automatically determine what future legislation must say. They do, however, establish important principles that Parliament will need to consider.

Italy’s Next Chapter Depends on More Than Court Decisions

The November judgments represent both progress and unfinished business.

Civil partners can now jointly adopt the same adult in circumstances permitted by law. Meanwhile, the ordinary joint international adoption route remains unavailable to them, and the Court has left broader reform for Parliament to address.

For families affected by the restriction, there is no automatic timetable for change.

The legal debate now concerns whether Italy’s adoption framework should continue to distinguish between married couples and other legally recognised relationships, and what evidence should guide that decision.

After years of incremental court rulings, the next decisive development would be a comprehensive parliamentary examination of eligibility, parental suitability and children’s welfare.

Italy has recognised that its understanding of family has changed. The unresolved question is whether Parliament will bring the law into line with the reality of the families already living within it.

Share this article
Raffa
Raffa

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *